News RSS Feed


Local Business Directory

Residents voice concerns over Harrow Council plans to cut library staff


DISGRUNTLED library users have hit out at plans to cut staff by a third and replace them with automated book checkouts.

Harrow Council last week unveiled its latest cost-cutting idea – installing 22 supermarket-like checkouts across the borough's nine library.

This would pave the way for up to 42 staff being axed from library services, saving more than £1m a year in salaries.

But Thelma Matthews is one library user who is opposed to the plans and has called on residents to fight against any redundancies.

She said: “The library staff are wonderful people – absolutely fabulous. You run libraries for people and you need people there to run them.

“I am happy to do anything to stop this because it is not what people want. I have spoke to a lot of people and they feel the same.

“Quite honestly, hands off our libraries.”

The Canons Drive resident fears automated machines will mean books are not available, they will get damaged, and the service to residents will suffer as a consequence.

She added she has spoken to staff at Stanmore Library and says they are “very concerned” at the plans which have been unveiled.

The council argues the machines, which are in use at other libraries across the country, will actually improve the service available.

Cllr Rekha Shah, who is overseeing the proposed plans, said: “The machines will provide customers with a faster service but unfortunately, it means we need to retain fewer library staff.”

Commenters on the Harrow Times website also questioned the idea, with one, Jackdaw, saying: “ Harrow's library staff are informed and helpful.

“Replacing staff with an automaton is not a wise decision. Machines break down and fail to work unlike Harrow's library staff.”

Richard at Harrow adds: “I want more info from the council like how many managers are employed and at what cost. I bet I could protect the front line while cutting back on under-employed managers.”

His concerns echo those raised by union Unison last week, who accused the council of “destroying” frontline services while protecting high paid managers within the authority.

But the council hit back, arguing it is streamlining management levels so that there is a maximum of five levels between senior officials and low paid workers.

It added that the review of services – part of a £50m cost cutting programme over the next three years – is aimed at providing value for money.

The consultation into the library service cuts has been launched, and a final decision whether to pursue the programme is expected to be made in October.

Comments(8)

jackdaw says...
11:37am Tue 10 Aug 10

The fee for reserving a book is now 90p.
If the book is not on Harrow library shelves and has to be requested from a library outside the Borough a fee of £5 is charged making a total of £5.90 per item.

This sum would be part way to paying for many books making it better to buy the book from somewhere like Amazon.

So fewer people will use the libraries thus leading to a perceived fall in demand and library closure.

martinbruce says...
9:41pm Tue 10 Aug 10

As someone who lives in Harrow and works in Brent I used use to both library services. However, Brent recently introduced these self-service machines and the system works so badly that I stopped using Willesden Green Library. The machines often do not work and now that the counter has gone it is very difficult to find a member of staff. When you do find one they are spending all their time programming the books so that the machines can read them. I've always found the staff there very friendly, but now there are fewer of them and they have no time for anything except trying to make these machines work properly. The staff at Harrow are very good at dealing with enquiries, but this element of the service will vanish if so many of them are sacked and the remainder have to tackle the kind of machines which Brent has and which are even worse than those in supermarkets.

kiss says...
5:30pm Wed 11 Aug 10

Article says up to 42 staff saving more than £1m pounds.
Thats almost £24,000 per person. This looks a high estimate.
Is it high because it includes other costs of employment , national insurance; pension etc.?

voiceoftreason says...
8:50pm Wed 11 Aug 10

I would assume that, like you have stated, the £24,000 includes all on-costs (National insurance and income tax, insurance, sickness, maternity, pensions & employee benefits etc).

Yogesh says...
1:40pm Thu 12 Aug 10

The statement “The council argues the machines, which are in use at other libraries across the country, will actually improve the service available.” Can they please provide which libraries in the country utilise the machines so that residents of Harrow can talk those libraries and council to determine the exact nature of the improved services?

The statement by Cllr Rekha Shah, “The machines will provide customers with a faster service…” Do Harrow libraries suffer with queuing problem? How many customers are waiting to be served at the same time? Have appropriate modelling processes being undertaken to see how much time will be saved and how fast the service will become?

As per Unison quote “the council “destroying” the frontline services…” was this part of Labour manifesto? We were told the frontline services will be saved at all cost. The question that needs to be asked is how much will this new technology cost and where is the breakdown to show the savings, if there is any. How long will it take for Harrow to realise the savings? What is the timescale?

Irony is that Labour in their manifesto stated the opening of libraries on Sunday’s and now they are cutting back on staff – Why oh Why

Will all the information be available in the consultation document – wow!!!

voiceoftreason says...
8:19am Fri 13 Aug 10

Guys, I don't think this has got anything to do with service improvement. The Council, like every other local authority across the country, has NO money. I don't think people realise quite how bad the financial situation is, and it is going to get far worse. The loss of some library staff wiill be the least of our concerns in the coming months. Public services are going to be destroyed.

kiss says...
3:18pm Fri 13 Aug 10

"...It added that the review of services – part of a £50m cost cutting programme over the next three years – is aimed at providing value for money...."

Most people understand the financial difficulties facing the country. Value for money is fine. However the new labour council do not want to engage with the public as to which local services shoudl be cut over the next few years. As a start they should open up the council wage book for scrutiny.

Davidz says...
9:34am Mon 16 Aug 10

I agree.

Public Services will be destroyed - the first wave of attack already started by central Tory-LibDem Govt and then local councils of all hue and colours have to fall in line to make the saving forced by the cuts. Some of them rightly so. The situation has been made extremely worse by the fact that Harrow and other councils facing in-year cuts forced by the Government of about up to £3-4 million, meaning that they MUST stop, close, shut down, cut to the projects already in existence or services as well as to the jobs.

Harrow Council must find, as a result of Government actions and policies, £50-60 million worth of cuts in next 3 years! Now let’s just pause and think! How would that be really possible?

What is that central coalition Government wants Councils to do, coming up with new cuts and policies affecting areas and people almost on weekly/monthly basis – be it primary school milk fiasco or cuts to free swimming for children and others in the middle of summer holidays?

In fact, if you look at the national picture I feel that this is just the start, the planned Spending Review in Sep/Oct by the Government may just really set the local Government on fire.

As for the Council opening up the wage book, it is a good idea.

Is the Council listening?


Most popular






Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses